Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A self driving car should have no steering wheel. If it has a steering wheel it is a vote of no confidence from the manufacturer.


I don't really buy that. There are a lot of situations (e.g. being directed to park in a space at a fairgrounds, ski area, or whatever) that you can't reasonably expect AFAIK to be programmed into a car's computer. Even if a car can legitimately handle roads under most circumstances, they're not going to be able to handle everything.


"Because the Origin does not have manual controls, the NHTSA must issue an exception to the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards to permit operation on public roads"

Too bad that project failed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cruise_(autonomous_vehicle)


I think their point was "it's not ready yet."


Throttle and yoke aren't a vote of no confidence from aircraft manufacturers. Some modes of operation are suitable for autopilot and some are not.


There is a reason that pilots get basically told the ins and outs of a specific plane. Imagine the outrage if people need to do month long training for a specific car just to be able to drive it (and not just a general "here is how cars roughly work and the laws of the road").


Would it be a vote of no confidence in Full Self Flying?


No, it would be an acknowledgement of the lack of perfection in human systems so far.


I mean, they kinda are.

Airline pilots aren't supposed to take a nap, and there are occasionally articles about the various things that have gone wrong because the pilots weren't paying attention.


That presents an interesting failure mode challenge.


Well we don't have any self driving cars outside of San Francisco. Only cars with advanced driver assistance.


Quite a few more places have them now:

https://support.google.com/waymo/answer/9059119?hl=en


Also in Vegas (Zoox), and China has their own competitive market of self-driving taxis.


How do you reverse such a car into your own driveway that's positioned in a funny way at an angle and an incline? What if you're parking off road for any reason? Like, you have to be able to manoeuvre your own vehicle sometimes.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: